Why Most Blogs Struggle with Increasing and Sustaining Email Newsletter Subscribers – and How to Fix It
Email newsletters remain one of the best ways to directly engage your audience—if you can get people to open and read them. The challenge becomes far more complicated when your blog covers multiple topics or a wide range of interests. After all, readers only have so much attention to spare, and every email they receive competes against countless others in their inbox. In this scenario, a “one-size-fits-all” newsletter can backfire. Subscribers quickly unsubscribe or simply ignore future emails when they see content irrelevant to their interests or when they feel overwhelmed by the volume of messages.
This problem is particularly acute for “generalist” or broad-topic blogs that don’t stick to a single subject area. Suppose your site covers travel, tech, and lifestyle. A subscriber might be passionate about tech but completely uninterested in your latest travel posts—and vice versa. Over time, that mismatch leads to poor open rates, dwindling subscriber numbers, and overall newsletter fatigue.
In this post, we’ll explore why many newsletters fail under these circumstances and how you can adapt your approach to maintain an engaged, satisfied subscriber base. We’ll also discuss the two most common newsletter models—post-by-post and summary/digest—their pitfalls, and how to overcome the inherent challenges of sending regular emails that capture readers’ interest.
Two Common Newsletter Models
1. Immediate Post-by-Post Emails
What It Is:
You send an email every time you publish a new blog post. Sometimes this email includes the entire post, while other times it includes a teaser or excerpt with a link to read more on your site.
Why It’s Popular:
- Instant gratification: Your most dedicated subscribers get new content as soon as it goes live.
- Great for blogs that post infrequently (e.g., once or twice a week), ensuring subscribers never miss a single update.
Pitfalls for Broad-Topic Blogs:
- Inbox Overload: If you publish multiple posts a week (or daily), subscribers’ inboxes fill quickly with your updates.
- Irrelevant Content: If half your posts don’t interest a given subscriber, repeated unwanted updates can lead to quick unsubscribes.
- Limited Time: Readers are busy; many prefer a summary approach rather than sifting through multiple emails.
2. Regular Summary or Digest Emails
What It Is:
A weekly, bi-weekly, or monthly roundup of your latest or best-performing posts, often with short summaries or teasers to help readers decide if a post is relevant to them.
Why It’s Popular:
- Reduced Email Volume: Subscribers get fewer emails, which can help prevent newsletter fatigue.
- Curated Value: You can highlight only the most interesting or relevant posts, making the newsletter feel more like a “mini magazine.”
Pitfalls for Broad-Topic Blogs:
- Varied Interests: If you feature everything you published that week, some portion of it may not appeal to every subscriber.
- Topic Mismatch: Even in a digest, multiple headlines might still feel irrelevant to someone who came for just one or two of your blog’s categories.
- Diluted “Wow” Factor: If the digest is too jam-packed, each piece of content might seem less special.
Why Irrelevant Content Leads to Newsletter Failure
1. Limited Time and Inbox Competition
Inboxes are crowded. People subscribe to several newsletters, and they’re quick to unsubscribe if your messages don’t consistently feel worth their time.
2. Mismatch of Interests
No matter how great your posts are, if they don’t match what a subscriber wants to read, they’re unlikely to click—or even open future emails.
3. Volume Overload
Sending every single post to every subscriber can overwhelm them, especially if your blog publishes multiple posts per week on topics they only marginally care about.
1. Segment Your List by Interests
What It Is:
Give subscribers the option to choose which categories or topics they want to hear about.
How to Do It:
- During signup, let readers select from your main content themes (e.g., Travel, Tech, Lifestyle).
- Use an email marketing platform (e.g., Mailchimp, ConvertKit, ActiveCampaign) that supports segmentation.
- Tag posts by category, then ensure only subscribers who opted into that category receive the email.
Why It Works:
- Reduces unsubscribe rates by minimizing irrelevant emails.
- Increases open and click-through rates, since recipients see posts they’ve specifically requested.
Potential Drawbacks:
- More complexity in your email setup.
- If your audience is small, segmenting might feel like extra work—but it typically pays off as you scale.
2. Curate a Digest of Only the “Best” or Broadly Appealing Posts
What It Is:
Send a periodic (weekly, bi-weekly, or monthly) newsletter featuring only the most engaging or top-performing content.
How to Do It:
- Identify posts with the highest engagement, shares, or comments.
- Write short, compelling summaries or bullet points to tease the content.
- Provide links to read more, so the email is relatively short.
Why It Works:
- Decreases email frequency (no daily updates), reducing fatigue.
- Focuses on quality over quantity, giving subscribers a curated experience.
Potential Drawbacks:
- You might leave out niche posts that a small but devoted audience might love.
- Not suitable for time-sensitive or “breaking news” content, since your roundups are delayed.
3. Offer Multiple Frequency Options
What It Is:
Let subscribers choose whether they get every post as it’s published, a weekly roundup, or a monthly highlight.
How to Do It:
- During signup, present frequency preferences (e.g., “Email me as soon as there’s a new post,” “Send me a weekly digest,” or “I only want a monthly summary”).
- Create separate segments or flows for each frequency.
- Automate the process so people receive the email schedule they selected without manual intervention.
Why It Works:
- Caters to different reading habits and preferences.
- Minimizes unsubscribes from people who feel overwhelmed by too many emails.
Potential Drawbacks:
- Increased complexity in managing different automation flows.
- You need to keep track of new content, so it’s correctly funneled into daily/weekly/monthly newsletters.
4. Personalize Based on Behavior
What It Is:
Leverage email marketing tools to track what types of articles each subscriber opens or clicks on. Over time, dynamically tailor newsletters to surface more of what they’ve already shown interest in.
How to Do It:
- Use an email provider that supports behavioral tagging and dynamic content blocks.
- Automatically “tag” subscribers based on links they click (e.g., “tech lovers,” “travel fans”).
- Customize the newsletter to highlight the content categories people are most engaged with.
Why It Works:
- Highly relevant email content reduces the risk of “this isn’t for me” moments that lead to unsubscribes.
- Improves click-through rates by aligning content with established preferences.
Potential Drawbacks:
- Requires advanced email marketing software and thoughtful setup.
- May be overkill for a small audience unless you’re planning significant growth.
5. Deliver Exclusive Content
What It Is:
Rather than sending only your blog posts, offer special or behind-the-scenes insights exclusively via email.
Examples:
- Insider tips or extra advice not found in your regular blog posts.
- Early access or sneak peeks of upcoming content.
- Personal stories or “storytelling-style” emails that go beyond the normal scope of your blog.
Why It Works:
- Creates a sense of exclusivity: unsubscribing means losing access to this bonus material.
- Helps readers feel part of an “inner circle,” fostering loyalty.
Potential Drawbacks:
- Requires extra time to craft unique email-only content.
- You must remain consistent—promising exclusive material but rarely delivering can erode trust.
6. Explore Alternatives (or Complements) to Email
If managing segmentation, personalization, or frequent sends feels overwhelming, remember that email might not need to be your only channel. Consider:
- RSS Feeds: Let dedicated fans follow you via tools like Feedly.
- Browser Push Notifications: Immediate alerts for new posts—subscribers can opt in or out.
- Social Channels: Share new posts on Twitter, Facebook, LinkedIn, etc. Readers can choose to follow you there instead of via email.
These can be used alongside a newsletter, giving your audience control over how they stay updated.
7. Send Fewer, High-Impact Emails
What It Is:
If you produce lots of posts, it might be more effective to significantly reduce email frequency—perhaps just one monthly deep-dive or “mini-magazine.”
How to Do It:
- Select the top 2–5 posts or topics each month.
- Write an engaging editorial note that ties them together.
- Include strong visuals to make the email feel polished and valuable.
Why It Works:
- Less frequent emails mean subscribers are more likely to open them because each edition seems special.
- You can focus on creating a high-quality experience instead of juggling frequent sends.
Potential Drawbacks:
- Readers might forget they subscribed if the interval is too long.
- Not ideal for time-sensitive or rapidly changing content.
Conclusion: Crafting a Newsletter Strategy for Diverse Content
When your blog covers multiple topics—or publishes a wide variety of content—managing an email newsletter can be daunting. The traditional one-size-fits-all approach of sending every post to every subscriber often leads to increased unsubscribes and diminished engagement. However, with thoughtful segmentation, curated digests, or user-driven frequency settings, you can keep a broad audience happy without overwhelming them.
Key Takeaways:
- Avoid Sending Everything to Everyone: Use segmentation, customization, or curated picks to keep newsletters relevant.
- Let Subscribers Choose: Frequency and topic preferences go a long way toward making people feel in control of their inbox.
- Personalize Whenever Possible: Tailor content to user behavior or stated interests for higher open and click rates.
- Offer Exclusive Value: Reward subscribers with unique material, making the newsletter itself part of your blog’s appeal.
- Consider Alternatives: RSS feeds, push notifications, or social channels can lighten the email load for both you and your readers.
By employing these strategies, you can maintain a strong, engaged newsletter audience—even if your blog’s content spans multiple themes. Done right, newsletters remain a powerful way to connect, drive traffic, and cultivate long-term relationships with your readership.
Related Posts:
All comments are held for moderation. We'll only publish comments that are on topic and adhere to our Commenting Policy.