The Rise of Substack – How Substack Is Changing The Way We Talk About Blogging
For those of us who’ve been writing on the internet since the early days — publishing on WordPress, tweaking our themes late into the night, crafting our own blogrolls and self-hosted ecosystems — something subtle but significant is happening:
People don’t say “blog post” anymore.
They say: “I wrote a Substack.”
It’s more than just a language quirk. It signals a tectonic shift in how we think about writing online — what counts as legitimate, discoverable, and share-worthy — and it poses an interesting question to those of us who still proudly publish via WordPress: What does it mean to be “independent” in a world of platforms that feel more like networks than tools?
From “Blog” to “Substack”: A Shift in Cultural Capital
Once upon a time, saying “I wrote a blog post” was enough. It implied independence, creativity, and commitment. Now, “blog” has become slightly unfashionable in certain circles — not because the format is outdated, but because the vibes have shifted.
When someone says “I wrote a Substack,” they’re not just describing a format. They’re signaling legitimacy. It suggests they’re part of a larger ecosystem, that they might be making money from their words, and that their work isn’t just floating in the void — it’s subscribed to.
This is branding at work. Substack has done what few platforms manage to do: make people want to say its name out loud in casual conversation. (Think: “I Googled it,” “I’m on Spotify,” “Follow me on TikTok.”) When’s the last time someone said “I WordPressed it”?
The Value of the Platform — and the Power of the Subdomain
Here’s another interesting dynamic: many Substack writers use the default yourname.substack.com URL — and they prefer it. That’s a quiet reversal of web development wisdom.
For years, self-hosted custom domains were the badge of honor. If you were serious, you owned your domain. But now, in the age of trust-based content discovery, a .substack.com domain arguably carries more credibility than your own .com. Why?
- It signals you’re part of a trusted platform.
- It carries the implicit promise of design consistency, readability, and built-in subscribe/pay options.
- It feels more “networked” than “isolated.”
And — let’s be honest — it’s free. No domain registration, no SSL headaches, no $19.99 renewals, no worrying about DNS settings or plugin conflicts or caching issues.
Substack turned “platform lock-in” into a feature. And for many writers, it’s a welcome trade-off.
Discovery in the Age of AI and Algorithmic Blindness
This might be the most crucial point: discoverability.
If you’ve ever posted a brilliant piece to your self-hosted WordPress blog and watched it disappear into the digital ether, you’re not alone. In the age of AI summaries, zero-click answers, and search results dominated by SEO farms, being “out there on your own” doesn’t guarantee visibility. It often guarantees obscurity.
Platforms like Substack, Medium, and even Ghost (to a lesser extent) are winning not just because they’re easier — but because they’re networked.
They have recommendation engines.
They surface your posts to new readers.
They make the next click obvious.
The personal blog — unless paired with strong social channels or a dedicated audience — is increasingly invisible to the average web user.
That’s hard to admit for those of us who love WordPress. But it’s true.
So… Is WordPress Still Worth It?
Yes — but with nuance.
WordPress is still the most flexible, powerful, open-source publishing platform on the planet. It gives you control that Substack never will. You can run a membership site, customize every pixel, own your SEO, syndicate your feed, and build something that truly belongs to you. For developers, entrepreneurs, and niche creators, WordPress remains unmatched.
But if you’re primarily a writer, and your goal is to be read and shared, the Substack shift is worth paying attention to. Not because WordPress is obsolete — but because the reader behavior has changed. People now expect to follow writers via email, not bookmarks. They expect a frictionless reading and subscribing experience. They expect the platform to help them discover you.
That’s the trade-off. You either:
- Own everything, but do all the work of growth and trust-building yourself
- or
- Lease space inside a growing ecosystem, and benefit from the built-in network effect
Neither is “better.” But they offer different paths.
Final Thought: Maybe the Blog Was Always a Community Thing
Here’s the kicker: blogging was never really about total independence. Even in the early days, blogs thrived in networks — Blogrolls, webrings, comment sections, and cross-links were the social layer before social media. The web has always favored clusters over islands.
Substack, like WordPress.com once did, is just the latest expression of that truth. It’s not replacing the blog; it’s re-networking it.
So maybe the smartest move isn’t to abandon WordPress — but to acknowledge that in 2025, if you want to be found, read, and shared, you need to live in more than one neighborhood.
TL;DR for the WordPress die-hards:
- People say “I wrote a Substack” now because platforms shape perception.
- Substack subdomains often feel more legitimate than your own
.com. - Discovery is broken on the open web unless you’re part of a trusted network.
- WordPress is still incredible — but harder to grow without external hooks.
- The blog isn’t dead — it’s just evolving into a platform-native, networked creature.
Related Reading:
All comments are held for moderation. We'll only publish comments that are on topic and adhere to our Commenting Policy.